Friday, October 30, 2015

Thinking About Why People Flee Persecution in Latin America To Come to America / Immigration #2)

Tonight I attended an event at my church which could well have served as a prequel or sequel to Wednesday night's event, protesting the for-profit family detention center near Hutto, where 27 women started a hungry strike last night. (Which, reportedly, a prison spokesman told the media today is "just a rumor")  


Tonight we watched the 1 1/2 hour film “Resistencia: The Fight for the Aguan Valley” detailing the 2009 coup in Honduras. It is a sobering, engaging, disturbing documentary depicting how some families in Honduras were/are getting regularly screwed out of not just jobs but land and opportunities not to mention things like health care. Not to mention elections that are fraudulent and those who raise questions about the government being found murdered.  

There were comments, and questions answered, after the film by María Luisa Rosal, a Guatemalan-American whose family sought political asylum in the U.S. after her father was disappeared during the worst intensification of the internal armed conflict in Guatemala during the 80s.  

These days she is a field organizer for the School of Americas Watch, using her firsthand knowledge and Bachelor's Degree in Political Science from Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond, Virginia and Masters Degree in Human Rights and Democratization in Latin Amercia and the Caribbean from the Universidad Nacional de San Martín in Buenos Aires, Argentina.  

Some of the key leaders destroying and disrupting life in both Guatemala and the Hondursas were products of the long controversial School of the Americas.  

It was while she was talking that something clicked that made this more than just two nights in a row of social action work for me. It was when she began talking about the increased level of immigration efforts last summer not just from Mexico but from people of Central American nations like, yes, Guatemala and the Honduras.  

That's when I clicked that in a way that I had gone, essentially, full circle. She explained about the increasing numbers of not just families trying to immigrate from Central America to America but a hike of unaccompanied minors coming across the border.  

And where are some of those folks being caught being put?  

Well, some of the women have been placed, without bond and with processing often taking longer than one year, in the very detention center I joined Grassroots Leadership and others in protesting last night.  


Indeed, the 27 women risking retribution by going on the hunger strike are from El Salvador, Guatemala, Nicaragua, Honduras, Mexico, Brazil and Europe.  


And if the families had kids they may well be placed in a for-profit family detention center near Dilley, Texas, where Grassroots Leadership and other groups helped organize a protest For that one 600 people marched together... and it made headlines nationwide and offered hope and inspiration for many.  


So, yes, I'm not sure it was planned that way but the events of Wednesday and Thursday were like connecting jigsaw puzzles Sometimes when you read the news it's hard to see how one story connects to another. Not this time. 

Thursday, October 29, 2015

Protesting/Rallying At Family Detention Center As Hunger Strike Starts/Immigration part #1


( A sequel to this piece is here - read this one first)


I was invited to this event. Code name was "tamale sale," I guess to avoid tipping off the detention center. Turns out it was this hunger strike.
I created a photo album here 
and wrote up this report:  
I attended tonight an amazing protest/rally outside the Hutto Family Detention Center. While it's not called a jail or prison it sure looks like one. It used to also house children but campaigns to stop that... did stop it... only for them to build a family detention center outside of Dilley,TX, which houses immigrant women and children.  


The groups organizing tonight's event were also involved in a march a few months ago protesting the Dilley facility. I wrote about that one at the time and will try to dig it up and post it here soon.
For that one 600 people marched together... and it made headlines nationwide and offered hope and inspiration for many.  

Tonight's event was, by design, smaller but it was not intended to be large, as word of the event was kept mum for obvious reasons.  


Grassroots Leadership, which was involved in both events, describes family detention centers this way: "Family detention is the practice of holding immigrant families, including children and babies, in prison-like detention centers with their parents. These detention centers are often operated by for-profit, private prison companies. " 

Tonight's event was to mark the start of a hunger strike by 27 of the women inside thus the hashtag ‪#‎Hutto27‬ .We wanted to let not only the world know of the start of their hunger strike but more importantly for the detention center to be aware that we were watching to see if there was retribution against those women.  

We, people from various groups, including several of us from First Unitarian Universalist of Austin, including Rev. Marisol Caballero, were there to let those inside know we were there in spirit and body to support them.  

From our location at a baseball field on property adjacent to the detention center we were able to see some of the women in an outside exercise area and they cheered our protests, while we cheered in response.  

I felt pride, especially in that moment, that I was participating in something positive and meaningful, a much better use of my time than what I would have been doing tonight, namely writing smart ass remarks about the election debates.  


As my photo album shows we not only chanted about justice and supporting them in their struggle but we also listened as people read from the letters written by some of the women explaining why they are taking what can be a dangerous step of going on a hunger strike.  
While there have been some victories of folks who have been on hunger strikes there have also been cases of forced feeding... of detention centers taking away water from those on hunger strikes, and other penalties and forms of retribution.  

"Eighteen women wrote letters exposing the injustice they have experienced during their detention including a dysfunctional legal system, verbal abuse, rancid food, and inadequate medical care. These conditions reveal the moral bankruptcy of detention and why the women have decided to risk a hunger strike to demand their freedom," Grassroots Leadership wrote in an email announcing the event,  


"The women at Hutto join 54 South Asian immigrants at the El Paso Processing Center and 14 at the LaSalle Detention Center in Louisiana who began hunger strikes last week."  
As we protested and chanted we could hear nearby residents also shouting. 

At first there was a moment of unease as we looked at each other to see what they were saying. Then we understood. 

"Let them go! Let them go!" the neighbors shouted about those inside the facility.
We looked at each other and smiled. 

"Let them go!" we shouted back.  

By the end of the night we had some of these neighbors joining us in planning for both continuing this event into the future as well as possible future events. (I'm not going to go into detail here on what the future events will look like as i'm not sure if they want that publicized yet. You can contact me privately about that, if interested in helping.)  
We started with maybe 25 people but then others kept arriving, some who have known about the event for a week or more and some who saw the announcement by email - that went out at 5:30 pm announcing the 6:30 pm event - and came out immediately.  


By the time the event ended around 8 pm we'd grown to 50 people including at least ten people from homes less than 200 yards from the prison property.  
Perhaps we can take a page from the People's Task Force of Austin's playbook, whereby they first do an event with limited turnout. then repeat the event... and repeat it... with the turnout increasing each time, some times doubling the prior turnout, until the actions desired start to take place.  
Meanwhile, the groups have another excellent and creative plan under consideration.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  
At one point a group of us walked from the baseball field to the front office of the detention center. The goal was for one or two people, Marisol volunteered to be one of them, to talk to the detention center employees, to let them know that we know there is a hunger strike taking place inside and we will be watching in case there is retribution against those women.... either by the facility or by ICE or other immigration offices.  
Some of us, myself included, were taking photographs and as we approached the front doors there was concern about phones with cameras perhaps being confiscated. Then the point became moot.  


You can see what happened in my photo album: They simply locked the door. Technically, it is visiting hours until 8 pm - this happened at 7:30 pm - and I made sure to photograph a friendly sign encouraging folks to come inside and visit the facility.  
Instead, the door was locked and they watched us try to talk to them.. and I'd say they ignored us except that they watched us... and we took pictures and video of them not letting us inside to talk... and I head reports they started taking videos of us in return.  
We begged to at least let us pass on a note. I heard later the note said something to the effect of, "Hey, we should talk, we hear there's a hunger strike brewing."  
Then two guys came up to us who identified themselves as police (I couldn't tell what law enforcement agency they were from as the detention center is, despite its name, closer to Taylor than to Hutto.) They were not answering any questions though I believe one did agree to take the note.  


We were escorted away from the building.. and back to the road leading away from the facility. There was a lady there with an employee badge. 

"Do you work here? Can you talk to us?" I asked.
"The police said to move," she replied. 

"Can you at least answer my question," I said, as traces of my former life as a journalist were returning.
"The police said to move," she repeated.
I obeyed.
We also told the police and the anonymous worker that we'd talk later... perhaps we will return as soon as tomorrow night.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  
We met back up with the rest of the group and, standing in a circle, shared orally our results, learning that while we were trekking to and from the facility the others were talking with some of the neighbors and learning of shared objections to the event, with one of the area kids summing up in perfect kid speak their thoughts about the situation, about these women held without bond for so long.  
"That's messed up," is what the area kid said of the situation.  
It sure is, kid, it sure is.  


And so we made plans to keep our eyes on the situation, figuratively and physically, by sharing this situation and struggle via social media as well as sometimes, in person near the detention center,  


It may be "messed up" but it's not only the neighbors who have their eyes on that place. ...
It's not just our group that was there either.....
Now, thanks to the beauty of the internet, the whole world is now watching.  


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  
Here's a more detailed explanation by Grassroots Leadership of what happened tonight and why,as well as a petition you can sign:
https://grassrootsleadership.ourpowerbase.net/…/petit…/sign…  
You can read some of the letters here::
https://grassrootsleadership.ourpowerbase.net/…/ex…/url.php…  
Related: Here's a good primer explaning family detention centers and the related issues
are: http://grassrootsleadership.org/facts-about-family-detention 

Saturday, October 24, 2015

My Life Part #2 - The Austin Years (so far)

When I left off of Part One
(I’m using links as footnotes, essentially) - I'd arrived in Austin after a move where I met a bunch of different people - good folks, mind you, but its one thing to occasionally meet a few people offline who you knew online - it's another to drive to their homes.
It was fun but exhausting. I think when I arrived at my sister's home I spend longer than most would, needing some down time before I began looking for work. I think that was an example where I’d gone way outside my usual comfort zone as an introvert and my body was telling me to stay in bed until both body and brain were ready to adjust. Soon I did adjust and move on.
This shy introvert had gone from a small town in Maryland where I’d worked out my fear of public speaking by forcing myself onstage at open mics, in a town where they were only two establishments that had open-mic night, to Austin where I bet I can find five open mic nights per night if I wanted to. Which I didn’t. I stopped that practice after I moved... but soon found other ways to do social things.
My first six months in Austin was mixed, with rough moments mixed in with the positive ones.
A big positive step came when I found the First Unitarian Universalist Church of Austin and was hired to work there. I worked there for about one year but seven years later I'm still super active there. I wrote here about how I, dubbed Scottman by kids at the UU church in Frederick, Md., had found a new church: http://sbutki.newsvine.com/_news/20.... More about my activities at the church in a minute.
I had a series of interesting temp jobs, which provide a never-ending stories. The oddest was probably the first. I saw someone advertising for people doing data and hiring them at a higher than usual wage. Turns out it was a temp agency, er, staffing service, hiring folks to do work at the state Department of Public Safety. Seems there was a large backlog on applications for concealed weapons permits.
I took the job. It seemed hilarious - I move to Texas what with its stereotype of people with guns and cowboy hats and I wasn’t finding that many cowboy hats but soon I was among about 70 people processing these applications. Every week, on Fridays, about ten of us would be fired, because the project was taking too long and costing too much. At one point they offered to train some people to do a second job - I volunteered. I’d seen the first season of Survival and I knew that to survive this real life reality show I had to become more essential. If there’s interest in this job and some hilarious and some disturbing results ask me in the comments section.
Another temp job involved organizing more than five years of documents from a state agency into various groupings (one for faxes, one for agendas, one for written correspondence) and then sort them all chronologically. Except that the boss referred to it as “chronicological,” which never failed to spark at least one worker from having to hide a laugh what with Austin having its own fascination with “chronic,” aka high quality weed.
I also found work, most of seasonal, at Pearson aka the Dark Side aka the company both lobbying the state for more of those standardized tests parents and teachers alike dislike and then publishing said tests. My job was to score the tests. I met there two of my best friends, Gretchen Smith and Kirsten Clay.
I walked out of a library one day, headed to the Pearson job interview, to find someone had stolen my radio. This was the same morning NPR broadcast a story about car burglaries dropping in regularity. In my style I posted a letter to NPR suggesting they rebroadcast it for my burglar to hear. http://sbutki.newsvine.com/_news/20...
A darker moment took place when I came home to my apartment to find someone had broken into my apartment and stolen my most valuable items - a fancy SLR camera, tv and dvd player and computer. I wrote about it here http://sbutki.newsvine.com/_news/20... then focused later on why it rattled me so. http://sbutki.newsvine.com/_news/20...
Meanwhile, I wrote about how Austin differed from Maryland with pieces like this (http://sbutki.newsvine.com/_news/20...) as well as a version on facebook https://www.facebook.com/notes/scot...
Oh, and yes, while no longer a paid journalist I would still write memoir pieces and conduct writing exercise. I still wrote interviews with authors something I do to this day at a rate of one a month. I think if most people look at this index of interviews and reviews I've done they would recognize at least a few names with authors ranging from film critic Roger Ebert to Police drummer Stewart Copeland along with many mystery writers, memoirists, etc. in between. http://sbutki.new.newsvine.com/_new...
Soon after I arrived, South by Southwest happened. I decided to follow my interests which led me to a documentary called Horseboy. I didn't know much going in except that it'd be about a family who lived near Austin whose son was autistic and loved horses. I worried that, in this culture where, even more these days, too many people base decicions on science based on anecdote (thus the whole vaccine causes autism myth that I went out of my way to discredit in interviews over the years) this could lead to people saying, ah, so if I take my family to Mongolia, as this family did, where horses have more meaning than in America their son with autism will also progress.
I was pleased the movie didn't do that, it made it clear it was just one particular family's experience and they were not suggesting it was the cure-all for all families. I was more excited when I realized that in addition to interviewing just the director that the father, Isaacson had written a memoir too, and used the money from an advance to buy a horse ranch that is open for other families with children with autism to use.
Ultimately, I would interview not only the director and the father but also the son in question and his mom. And when I lost all those interviews in the home burglary they agreed to be interviewed a second time. I wrote separate interviews with all of them and they are indexed here http://sbutki.newsvine.com/_news/20... when, in a personal anomaly, I didn't finish the book until way after I'd actually published the interview. That was my one violation of my personal vow to read every book as part of an interview to avoid being those fake journalists on television and elsewhere who do interviews where it's clear they had no idea what the book involved.
I wrote memoir pieces and review pieces of various Austin coffee shops. And I wrote about the time I regained a car radio and, perhaps most importantly, resumed my relationship with NPR. http://sbutki.newsvine.com/_news/20...
Meanwhile, on the work front it took me a few years to get back into doing what I wanted, namely returning to working with folks with special needs. I ended up working full-time in group homes for a few years (working weekends which made it hard to build up a social life) and had other work before eventually getting work at a local school district where I worked for four years into last spring. At that point I decided, for a variety of reasons, to instead work in the homes of various families needing help. I currently have four jobs with four different families. This leads to lots of complicated schedule and taking advantage of “Obamacare” since none of my jobs are full-time.
Ok, so about that photo. That was me holding a sign while part of Occupy Austin. I grew up wishing I was born earlier so I could have participated in the heady history-making protests and matches in the 60s, particularly the civil rights struggles. It’s a time period I’m just fascinated with.
For years as a reporter I would write about protests, marches and other types of social aciton but be unable to participate or even comment on it because it’s important for journalists to appear neutral. While working temp jobs for the state and then working for a school district I still hesitated to participate in these actions for fear it’d lead me to lose a job.
But when the Occupy Wall Street movement began and Occupy Austin was created I had to take place. I participated in marches and organizational meetings and got a taste of what it was like to be on the street sweating your butt off, losing your voice screaming and chanting, your legs killing you and you’re making a difference in so many ways, or at least that’s your hope.
I posted a photo album of Occupy here.https://www.facebook.com/scott.butk... As my life got busier and it appeared Occupy was going to into different directions I stepped away. Later I learned there were one or two undercover cops amongst the group. We’d guessed that might be the case but it was crazier than anticipated. http://www.chron.com/news/houston-t...
Which reminds me I need to buy this book by Austin Chronicle photographer John Jack Anderson, who did an amazing job covering the Occupy Austin movement. You can learn more about the book here http://www.motherjones.com/media/20...
After I stepped away from Occupy Austin, I only did occasional protests and marches, often through my church.
I guess things became busy about six months ago. I became a more active participant in social actions, like joining 500 martches protesting the for-profit family detention center near Dillings, TX, http://www.texastribune.org/2015/05... and working with my church to provide sanctuary for a woman from Guatemala. http://www.austinchronicle.com/dail...
When Black Lives Matter Austin had its first rally, about a month ago now, I not only went but convinced some of the teenagers, from a church high school group I help run with Jairy Grisaffe, and their parents to attend as well as others. When that organization had its first organizational meeting I played a passive role, watching but wanting to help. So I stepped up and now am one of the leaders of the Allies for Black Lives Matter.
That put me outside my usual comfort zone but it felt good and right. Soon I was having two three to sometimes four nights a week taken up with marches and rallies and, more often, planning sessions.
Most recently, two weekends ago, I attended a Black Lives Matter Austin protest outside the Round Rock Police Department about the infamous choke hold on a black student.. That was the first part of my weekend and the last event of my weekend came when Meme Styles faciliated a panel at a church about not just that incident but how we can better improve the situation. I wrote about the experience here: https://www.facebook.com/scott.butk...
Doing these social actions is tricky at times because it’s hard to not look at events as someone who majored in journalism and minored in political science, meaning if i’m part of an event I am going to try hard to live in the moment but when I see what looks like the beginning of a potential news story I will have to stop myself from going to discover. But sometimes, I’ve realized, it can work to our benefit.
There’s cues and clues one can spot about problems happening right before it transpires. You have to watch for it and I do but it takes me out of the moment. I always ask those I’m attending events with whether they would be comfortable getting hurt and/or going to jail. This is like planning how much you will spend in Las Vegas. In both cases the answers to those questions helps dictate actions. So I try to help those around me get to where they need to go if violence and/or arrests do take place.
I am usually aware of the crowd size (an important thing for a reporter to know, as well as for a protest organizer to know since those numbers often don’t match the numbers police will provid) and how close the police are to me as well as determining where the trouble spots are at.
I work hard to take off that lens of a journalist and just focus on being in the moment: Feeling the satisfaction and pride of knowing i’m helping others in a cause I believe in, usually regarding race and immigration and inequities in society, in a direct physical way. For years I’d walked the walk and told others to walk that walk as well but now these days i’m not only walking but sometimes helping organize walks and rallies and getting others I know to participate too.
Watch my facebook page for notifications of upcoming events.
Between my special education work and my activist work I have come more and more out of my shell. I tell people these days that half my work is improv, meaning I'm not following specific plan while working these jobs so much as having a vague schedule but mostly going with whatever the person's interests or actions are and then just going with the flow. So if my charge needs to do some chores but wants to try again to beat me at Monopoly using his family’s house rules so be it and thus his “first.. then” becomes “first I do my chores then I play monopoly.” I even use first-then myself as in tonite, “first I finish this piece then I play one game of backgammon online and then I go to bed.
As improv comics say, when you do improv you don't question or say no - you say "yes and.." and go with it. Almost all the time I end up in a place where the person i'm working for has found more independence (one of my main goals) and/or is happier.
For example, when Austin Memorial Museum participated in National Fossil Day earlier this month I took my charge on a field trip there, required him to interview a paleontologist and write up a report. End result: He still wants to be a paleontologist even after learning to his chagrin most of them dont get a chance to even touch dinosaur bones.
Another charge is still getting used to being cared for and watched by someone who is not his mom, let alone saying more than his one sole word, “mommy.” Together we watch his favorite television program (“Everyone Loves Raymond” -I will explain in comments if you want that story) and chase and tag and hide and seek. But I’ve found he loves to look at himself in the mirror so I let him take selfies on my camera and he waves at himself and its cute and when doing all these things he forgets that I am accomplishing my job goal, namely to get him to feel comfortable in the case of someone besides his mom. And when, one day recently, he told me, unprompted “bye”, and the next time, “hello,” I was over the moon because those are the first times he said anything to me besides mommy.
So now I’ll do something improvs don’t do, namely stop:)
The end. Thanks for reading. Thanks to all who have helped him along the way, intentionally or not.
Thanks especially to Rev. Chris Jimmerson and Rev. Meg Barnhouse who have been what i’ll call my spiritual cheerleaders.

Tuesday, October 20, 2015

How A Shy Boy Who Preferred Books to Humans Became A leader of Clases and Programs aka My Life part #1

Part 1 of two - part two is here

I was talking to someone tonight and it got me thinking. I grew up a shy introvert and were it not for what look like the odd choice now to be a newspaper reporter - made total sense at the time, i'd get paid to write (having given up my prior career plan of being a famous best-selling novelist) and if i could stop apathy here and there that'd be great too.
Then after getting a college degree in mass communications, with an emphasis in journalism, and a minor in political science because I planned to be covering the White House by now for a major newspaper.
So for 15 years or so I was be in a position where i had to be outgoing and do more work with strangers then I was comfortable with. When not at work i'd prefer to be in my apartment reading alone. Didn't understand that about introverts and such back then - just thought of myself as shy. At work i'd talk too fast and too soft and that doesn't work when you're making phone calls to strangers on sometimes terrible things like getting comments after a terrible crime and sometimes just about local government news stories. "You're talking too fast, young man. Slow down and speak up!" God those were words i'd hate to hear.
At some point I realized it was probably not mentally healthy to be so shy outside work but increasingly outgoing at work. (Compartmentalized is the word I found for it years later)
So I started to do things like hanging out at Borders, back when Borders had comfortable chairs you can sit in for hours in coffee sections and between reading this and that and socialize with other regulars and justify it as flirting or checking out ladies and literally judging them by the covers of the books they read. They all got extra credit for being readers, though, having decided i'd rather date someone i met at a bookstore than at a bar. But I digress..
Then I decided i'd commit to attending performances at an open mic night in the same city, Hagerstown, Md. I'm ashamed now to admit i'd often be reading while others were performing but for me just to be there and listening and outside of my apartment.. that was a big step.
Then at some point I decided it was time to face some demons. And so Tommy Lancaster would let me go up and read aloud fiction or satire or columns i'd written. I was probably too soft and read too quick and I sweated through a lot of shirts but I got better at this.
It was my way of facing, straight on, my fear of public speaking. I tell this story these days and people are shocked that I did this. At the time it made perfect sense... and I guess it does now too, but was a very abrupt way to handle it. Some have used the word brave to describe it - I argue it was more an act of inertia and, ok, self-improvement.
Around this time I made a deal with myself: If i was invited to a social outing, be it playing or watching sports (i was and remain not a fan of most sports with cycling and swimming and soccer not being common fare) or watching tv or a movie I'd go. I kept my promise and started to get better at being comfortable outside of my home and work.
Somewhere in there I realized I had a problem of sorts: I was letting my job define my life. Thus I was a journalist and defined myself as such I'd give myself the online nickname of Scoop. Sure I'd pretend it was a nickname bestowed upon me by others but the reality was I'd started it.
And so when i began to get burnt out as a journalist realizing i'd never reach my goal of covering national politics and covering city and county governments were not the same.. .and covering the same issues... with the same peope.
Then cue personal crisis: If I was not a reporter... what was I?
I moved into education and then special education and while I'd sometimes define myself as a special education worker I was becoming other things: a leader of book clubs, and back when those were offline; a leader of online writing exercises; an interviewer of authors, something I continue to this day.
I was no longer just one thing. Just like now - and what started me thinking about this this week - I may do special education but i'm, increasingly in recent months and weeks, becoming more and more of an activist, a fighter of injustice, be it racism or police brutality.
After years of literally writing about injustices but being unable as a reporter to take public actions be it protests or marches, I was/am now able to do so and I seem to be making up for lost.
And so when I think now about how I've had weeks lately where I'm doing something every night after work how far i've come in just a few years, well, amazing. But i'm getting ahead of myself and sounding like my own cheerleader.
So instead I'll stop with this. In between jobs my sister suggested, "in the spirit of major change in this country" (this was about the time Obama was elected) that I leave Maryland to move to Austin where she and my nieces were. In Maryland and Arkansas before it I'd lived and worked with no family there... Now i had some family in Austin and my brother in L.A. and my mom back in Riverside,CA, where I grew up. I'd been to Austin with former girlfriend Joyce Homan to SXSW and loved the city.
Then I planned my move to Austin. And suddenly I realized, oh, boy, there's open mic nights there every night! (Back in Hagerstown I think it was just once or twice a week.. so less of a commitment.)
This was going to be interesting.
And then I did a major overreach: Rather than just drive from Maryland to Austin i'd make it a moving party of sorts. I announced my intentions at newsvine, where i was a very active writer and commenter (this was pre-facebook if memory serves) .
So I made an offer: I'd drive to meet you and your family in person. In exchange you put me up for a night. So it went, I met people in several states and slept in unfamiliar beds but avoided having to pay for hotels and met people with whom i'd been online friends for years. And that was exciting. But, wow, at some point I realized I was either driving or acting braver and more outgoing than I felt.
Then I made it to Austin.
The end... for now.....